top of page

The Difference Between Orthotics vs. Orthotic Shoe Inserts

skaters walking in city
Skater Couple walking in city

Orthotics come in several varieties, the three most common being custom orthotic shoes, custom orthotic inserts, and ready-to-buy shoe inserts. For our purposes, we are going to explore two popular options: orthotic shoes and orthotic shoe inserts. While both serve the same purpose, they come with distinct characteristics, benefits, and drawbacks. Additionally, sometimes the term “orthotics” is applied to any orthotic device, which is not an accurate representation–and it could lead to confusion when you’re shopping for the right option for you or a close loved one. In this blog, we'll unpack the differences between orthotic shoes and orthotic shoe inserts, outlining the pros and cons of each style.

Already know that orthotic shoe inserts are the way to go? Check out our curated online shop.

Understanding Orthotic Shoe Inserts: The Basics

Orthotic shoe inserts are removable devices that can be placed inside your regular shoes. They are designed to address specific foot issues such as overpronation, high arches, or plantar fasciitis among other things. These inserts can be purchased over-the-counter or custom-made by a podiatrist to match the unique contours of your feet.

Pros of Orthotic Shoe Inserts:

1. Versatility: One of the biggest advantages of orthotic shoe inserts is their adaptability. You can easily switch them between different pairs of shoes, allowing you to enjoy their benefits in various styles of footwear.

2. Cost-Effective: Ready-to-buy orthotic inserts are on average more affordable than buying multiple pairs of orthotic shoes. The quality of shoe inserts varies wildly, so be sure to purchase from an established brand that champions quality materials and customer success.

3. Swap Shoes: Orthotic shoe inserts are generally removable which means you can enjoy the benefits of that extra support in multiple looks. As long as the shape of the shoe is relatively similar to the shape of the orthotic, you can swap them out with most close-toed shoes.

Cons of Orthotic Shoe Inserts:

1. They aren’t custom: While inserts can provide relief and support, they might not offer the same level of stability and cushioning as a fully integrated orthotic shoe. People with certain conditions and ailments may need to consult with an orthotic specialist in these cases.

2. Fit Challenges: Over-the-counter inserts might not fit perfectly in every shoe, meaning sometimes you must customize the shape yourself with a pair of scissors. All in all, not a big project, but something to consider.

For the ultimate in comfort and quality, check out the Premium Orthotic Shop where we pack 35 years of medical technology into inserts that arrive on your doorstep.

couple walking dog
couple walking down European street

Understanding Orthotic Shoes: The Basics

Orthotic shoes are footwear designed with built-in orthotic features. Unlike regular shoes, orthotic shoes are engineered to provide comprehensive support and correct alignment, aiming to alleviate foot pain and improve overall body posture.

Pros of Orthotic Shoes:

1. Integrated Support: Orthotic shoes offer complete support from heel to toe, providing consistent alignment and cushioning. This integrated approach can be beneficial for individuals with chronic foot issues or those who require all-day support.

2. Purpose-Built Design: These shoes are meticulously crafted to cater to various foot conditions. They often include features like arch support, motion control, and extra cushioning, which can be particularly helpful for people with complex foot problems.

3. Convenience: With orthotic shoes, you don't need to worry about transferring inserts between different pairs of shoes. The support you need is already built into the footwear, saving you time and effort.

Cons of Orthotic Shoes:

1. Cost Considerations: Orthotic shoes tend to be more expensive than regular shoes or orthotic inserts as any specialty equipment tends to be. While orthotic shoes offer motion control, extra cushioning, and arch support, so does their more cost-effective counterpart, the orthotic shoe insert.

This upfront cost might be a drawback for some individuals, especially if quality insertable options are preferred.

2. Style Limitations: It’s function over form, generally speaking. While the range of orthotic shoes has expanded over the years, they might still lack the variety and fashion-forward options available in regular footwear. This could be a concern for individuals who prioritize both style and foot health.

3. Lack of Flexibility: The commitment to orthotic shoes means that you'll need to wear them consistently in order to experience the benefits. If you prefer different shoe styles for different occasions, this lack of flexibility could be a deal breaker.


Ultimately, the choice between orthotic shoes and orthotic shoe inserts depends on your individual needs, lifestyle, and preferences. Orthotic shoe inserts provide flexibility and affordability, making them an excellent option for those seeking specific support without committing to specialized footwear. And they’re a faster, more accessible solution than custom counterparts. On the other hand, orthotic shoes offer comprehensive and integrated support, making them ideal for individuals with more severe foot conditions or those who require all-day comfort.

Whether you opt for the adaptability of orthotic shoe inserts or the comprehensive support of orthotic shoes, prioritizing your foot health is a step in the right direction toward improved comfort and overall well-being.

Check out our Premium Orthotic read-to-buy options for relief right now.

31 views0 comments


bottom of page